Topic: Let's make a point system in Apollon.
Information:
・If people do something good for Apollon, they can get points in your point card and they can use points with the card in Apollon.
・Money for the system is given by the government.
・If we get all your oks, we'll discuss
1. How we can collect points
2. Where can we use them
・We are permitted to make the system by the government already.
・We'll make a website about the point system and we'll call for volunteers.
I ask them to make an application before.
Questions:
Lobert: What is the purpose of having people to make an application before?
Tama: If we collect applications before the activities, it is easy to give points correctly. If we check the volunteers after the activities, we don't know it is true that the man join the activity.
Lobert: What is written on the website?
Belle: The day when the activity is done, the contents of activities and how many points you can get points by the activity.
How we can collect points?
Jack: You can get points by joining the tour guide volunteers. They have to attend the program to learn knowledges about the guide and the tour company should hold the program.
Tama: Working as a staff of Sunflower-Festival.
Mac: Sunflower-Festival is holded once a year, so it is not enough chance to get points.
Tama: But, the festival is very important and big event, so it doesn't matter.
Mac: Buying the foods made in Apollon.
Jack: Participating in the contest of Sunflower-Festival.
Sophie: To every people who participate in the contest?
Jack: Yes.
Sophie: If we do so, we need much money.
Jack: It is no problem by giving few points.
Angelina: Recyclieg.
Where can we use?
Jack: Public utility cost, such as electric and water and gas cost, bus and train fee.
Mac: Shopping center.
Jack: The system is controlled by the government, so it is difficult to install the system to every shops.Mac: It is good to install the system to the shops that wants to do so.
Angelina: I think it is not good to use points for amusement and hobby, because we do good things to get points.
Laura: I don't think so. If we let people to use points for amusement and hobby, more and more people join the activities to get points.
Opinions:
Lobert: The money is from citizens' paying tax, so it is not good for us.
Tama: By the activity, we can cut the cost of public works. For example, if we draw the lines on the road by ourselves as a volunteer, we don't need money for it.
Belle: We have money problems. I think people do something good for Apollon by their goodwill, so it is volunteer. We can't give enough points, but I think volunteer is doing good things free. If you do public works as their job, you can more money than you can get by volunteers. However I want to value their goodwill.
conclusion:
we can't decide.
My comments:
I can't finish the discussion. It is difficult to think and explain about the money. I feel that it is the most important to decide the topic correctly.
You gave us a lot of information before discussion, and summarized every panelists' opinion. So I could understand the situation or meeting more than before. It is very hard to take a neutral stance, I think.
返信削除You gave question time to us at the early stage of the discussion. I think it is a good idea, but we weren't given enough information to judge if we were agree with the topic or not.
返信削除You did a good job as a moderator. Thanks to your summarizing, I could understand the discussion easily. If you take up the opinions by audience as issue, the discussion will be more lively.
返信削除The role of the moderator is to take a neutral standpoint, so I think you had difficulty in proceeding the discussion. The idea of asking some questions at the first time is not bad, but the fact remains that we were confused because we didn't have enough info to decide them. Then, you should have displayed your posision clealy at first.
返信削除Good job as a moderator! We, panelists, were very helped that you lead us to the consensus.
返信削除You did a good job as a moderator! Your topic was completely new to us, so it made us a little confused, but it was an interesting idea! If you listen to other opinions more, it would be better!
返信削除You tried to develop discussion as a modeletor so you did a great job.
返信削除Sometimes you seemed to be emotional a little.
If you just summarized each opinion and got ideas of panelists in shape, the discussion would be better, I think.
You gave us information and question time before the discussion. It was very good idea!! Besides, you summarized everyone's opinion, so I was easy to understand them.
返信削除I could understand you prepared for this discussion a lot but you couldn't use all your preparation. Your sammary was very useful for us to understand the panelists' opinions, Thank you.
返信削除Your group prepared some information concretly before the discussion, it's very good. However sometimes the setting made us confuse.
返信削除You did good job as a moderator. You tried to speak slowly and summarized each opinions, so I could understand easily. Thank you! However, I think you sometimes show your irritation, it was not good as a moderator.
返信削除I'm really sorry not to discuss and speak my opinion.
返信削除Thank you for being our moderator at this time.
Our discussion style was a gamble, and failure... But it is not your fault, don't blame yourself. Your delivery was good. I was relieved to see your smile. Let's try to make better discussion!
返信削除I know you struggled to be a good moderator and I think you did your best except the conclusion. I mean, at last, you concluded a bit forcibly without consideration to discussion's content. I wonder, what kind of information we got finally through the discussion.
返信削除It might be hard to do moderator in the style this time. It's thanks to you that we could do the discussion for all class time. Thank you.
返信削除You gave us enough time to talk with others, thank you. I think you were good moderator.
返信削除